The Economic Times
English EditionEnglish Editionहिन्दी
| E-Paper

    For no fault of theirs, PMC depositors may be in default


    Depositors could be tagged as defaulters if they fail to make repayments on loans.

    On September 23, the RBI suspended PMC Bank’s board after noticing major financial irregularities.
    MUMBAI: Thousands who service their loans through accounts at Punjab & Maharashtra Co-operative (PMC) Bank are staring at the risk of getting shut out of credit markets or increased cost of borrowings for no fault of theirs.

    These depositors at PMC Bank are unable to pay loan instalments due to a Reserve Bank of India-imposed cap on withdrawals, leading to defaults on repayments. They are likely to be classified as defaulters by credit information bureaus, which will make it difficult to get new loans.

    “There is definitely a second-order effect if customers are unable to withdraw their own money and service upcoming credit payments (whether) it’s on a credit card or some EMI. This could also impact businesses holding current accounts with the bank,” said Manu Sehgal, the business development leader at Equifax, a credit information bureau. “Payment defaults would obviously lead to a downgrade in the credit score.”

    On September 23, the RBI suspended PMC Bank’s board after noticing major financial irregularities, and capped withdrawals at Rs 1,000. The withdrawal limit has later been raised to Rs 40,000, after finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman discussed the matter with RBI governor Shaktikanta Das.

    Data with the bank show that it has 16 lakh depositors with total deposits of Rs 11,617 crore as on March. More than 60% of its customers had small deposits of around Rs 10,000 each in the bank.

    Customers who had taken a loan from PMC Bank and are unable to repay because of the withdrawal cap would also suffer as the default would get reflected in their bureau scores, said Parijat Garg, an industry expert and a former vicepresident at credit bureau Crif High Mark. “In the absence of any communication from the bank or the regulators, the credit bureaus will have to keep showing these non-payments as outstanding, although the customers were willing to pay. Those records will start becoming stale after a point.”

    In the past, the RBI had relaxed certain rules around classification of borrowers during material events like demonetisation and natural calamities that could affect the credit profile of borrowers. Industry watchers believe such a relaxation is required also in the event of bank collapses, as it mars customers credit scores.

    “In the past, the regulator has eased credit classification rules for a lot of microfinance institutions and banks… a moratorium or grace period could also be looked at in these scenarios,” said Sehgal of Equifax.

    The Economic Offences Wing of the Mumbai police has registered a case against Mumbai based realtor HDIL’s promoters Sarang and Rakesh Wadhawan and some officials of PMC Bank for allegedly causing losses worth Rs 4,355.43 crore to the bank.

    The Wadhawans and the bank’s suspended managing director Joy Thomas and former chairman Waryam Singh are currently in jail.

    Last week, Sitharaman indicated that the government might amend the laws on cooperative banks to prevent malpractices and ensure better regulation. A committee comprising secretaries of the departments of economic affairs and financial services, along with a deputy governor of the RBI, are expected to study the issue of better regulation and coordination among different ministries and states.
    (Catch all the Business News, Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on The Economic Times.)

    Download The Economic Times News App to get Daily Market Updates & Live Business News.

    24 Comments on this Story

    Ashwani Kumar Aggarwal408 days ago
    Lest We Forget - 19 th Century ''s Great and Devout Donor For Haridwar Pilgrims .
    When I was young , I remember reading an old inscription ( near enclosed Zenana Ghats ) at the upstream end of Har ki Pauri , Haridwar.
    The inscription was about when in 19 th century authorities imposed a Pilgrim tax of One Anna on every pilgrim visiting the Holy city of Haridwar
    This greatly upset a devout wealthy Hindu business man of that time. He vowed to undertake the responsibility on himself of paying the Pilgrim tax of all pilgrims and for all times to come .
    So , he paid a sum of Rs. One Lakh ( a princely sum then ) in return for a promise that never again would any tax be imposed on pilgrims visiting Haridwar.
    It seems the ever voracious tax collecting authorities ( not sparing even pilgrims and disregarding the solemn promise given to the great Donor ) deliberately first, shifted the inscription plate to a secluded place away from public gaze and then may have removed it altogether .
    Balachandra Kamath410 days ago
    The government should provide for full deposit insurance,
    In such a scenario, the insurance company will provide full insurance on the condition that due diligence is applied, and no wrong doing or financial misadventures are reported, it''s like a rating on the financial soundness, of the babk or lender, present rating agencies have failed us very badly in this matter.
    Once the insurance company fails to provide full deposit insurance, it is a clear case of red flags as far as safety of deposits are concerned and people will withdraw, or will never go near such institutions
    This is the only way one can bring some sense, among those who crave for financial misadventure, and in
    prima facie cases, people accused in such cases should be put to hard labour in infrastructure projects.
    No mercy, for such people, not just behind bars, but hard labour from day one.
    In this way a lot of our pending and future infrastructure projects, can be assured of cost effectiveness, and delivery schedules, as only jail food and accommodation will be provided, and a nominal service honanarium will be paid. Confiscation of assets of accused and their abbettors, on their conviction will be an added attraction.
    Subir Biswas410 days ago
    Really pathetic. But, this ingredient lies long for the indian banks due to poor deposit insurance coverage.
    The Economic Times