Smelling anomaly, watchdog may tighten rules for P-notes
Markets regulator Sebi has found instances where foreign brokers have issued P-notes against Indian derivative contracts to overseas clients, who don’t own the underlying local shares, thereby violating the regulation underpinning P-notes.
The capital markets regulator has found instances where foreign brokers have issued P-notes against Indian derivative contracts to overseas clients, who don’t own the underlying local shares. Instead, these brokers showed the shares they owned as the underlying instruments. As per regulations, P-notes in derivatives can only be issued for hedging, which means clients need to own the shares if they wish to buy the instrument.
Sebi may now ask brokers to keep shares they are treating as underlying instruments against Pnote derivative positions in a separate account, said two people aware of the development. The move would mean that foreign portfolio investor (FPI) brokers will be forced to buy new shares or transfer the existing ones in their own portfolio to the P-note subscriber account. Such a move will also increase tax liability, something the brokers are opposed to. P-notes can be issued by brokers against shares or futures and options positions.
The measure is likely to be a part of new operating guidelines for FPIs to be issued in next few weeks. The proposal will impact at least two of the top five P-note issuers in the Indian markets, which together have a market share of around 30 per cent, said one of the persons. The total value of P-notes issued stood at Rs 79,800 crore in August, Sebi data showed.
In 2017, the regulator had banned Pnote subscribers from taking any unhedged positions in the Indian derivative markets as part of its attempts to discourage use of the instrument. The government and Sebi have frowned upon the popularity of P-notes in the past as they are considered opaque because of constraints in identifying the end investor.
Until then, there were no restrictions on P-note subscribers in terms of trading or dealing in the markets. Hence, foreign brokers were issuing P-notes and underlying securities were held in their proprietary books.
Despite Sebi’s 2017 diktat, some of the leading FPI brokers continued to issue P-notes based on their proprietary books.
“In some cases, shares purchased for hedging purposes were kept in the prop accounts, while in a few others, no fresh purchase was made in order to comply with Sebi’s hedging rules,” said one of the persons. “If the proposed rule is implemented, the shares that have been purchased to hedge the P-notes issued need to be transferred to a different account and hence will be subject to several taxes, including capital gains and securities transaction tax.”