Sukhoi vs Sukhoi: India vs China


    The Su30MKI fleet is now the backbone of IAF and will continue to be so for the coming years. The Chinese air force, too, operates the Su30 fighters.

    India has decided to order 12 more Su30MKI fighter jets that will be made at Nasik by HAL under Russian licence. This new order will add to the 272 fighters of the type already ordered by the Indian Air Force. The Su30MKI fleet is now the backbone of IAF and will continue to be so for the coming years. The Chinese air force, too, operates the Su30 fighters. A comparison:

    IAF’s Su30MKI
    - With more than 260 fighters in service, Su30MKI forms the bulk of IAF. Additional jets are still being manufactured by HAL at Nasik and production will continue for next 2-3 years. The Indian versions are different from other Su30s as they are tailored to the needs of IAF
    - Designated MKI for India, the fighters have advanced Israeli avionics and an electronic warfare systems, making them different from the standard Su30
    - Indian fighters have demonstrated Brahmos firing capabilities
    - While they all have standard Russian origin R73/77 missiles, the Indian version will now be equipped with the longer-range Astra, the beyond visual range air-to-air missile developed by DRDO
    - This will add a critical new capability to the aircraft that has till now been hampered by limited range to take down air targets, compared to the western platforms
    - Though its beyond visual range combat ability is limited, at close quarters it has unbeatable capabilities


    PLAAF’s Su30 MKK/MK2
    - China operates two variants of Su30 but these aren’t as capable as the Indian version
    - Restrictions on the use of Israeli and western subsystems are one of the reasons
    - China had ordered 73 of the older MKK version and later added 24 of the MK2 version for its Navy

    However, unlike the MKI, the Chinese version does not have thrust vectoring engines, making them less manoeuvrable and nimble than the Indian fighters


    - China did not manufacture Su30s domestically, but it copied the design to make two indigenous versions called J11 and J16
    - J11, which is based on Su27 platform, is the backbone of PLAAF, with 346 of the type ordered
    - The more advanced version J16 is based on the Su30 platform and at least 128 are already in service. China has fitted the aircraft with indigenous weapons, including PL12 and PL15 air-to-air missiles

    Chinese also copied another Sukhoi variant, Su33 for its Navy
    Named J15, the aircraft carrier borne fighters have been copied from a suspected Ukrainian prototype that was surreptitiously acquired by China. At least 50 of these are believed to be in service
    (Catch all the Business News, Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on The Economic Times.)

    Also Read

    5 Comments on this Story

    Usindiajap 31 days ago
    China doesn't feel any shame for copying stealing others technoligy? What a Rogue Evil country.
    Anand v36 days ago
    Indian Airforce will get HAL AMCA by 2038 ........An obsolete AAMCA when all competitor will have 6 the gen fighter.............HAL IS SHAME FOR THE NATION
    Vaithianathan R M36 days ago
    Copy Cat Country even for jet manufacture. International rogues are International stealers as well. Shameless people, trying to avoid royalties to the country of original design and manufacture. Russia and Ukraine surprisingly has not said a word on the stealing of this technologies. Comrade Russia is watching as the world passes by under China's hegomonistic influence.
    The Economic Times