View: The economic battle, now that the political one’s won


    The central government has been shrinking in size (share of GDP). This needs to be recognised.

    With health and education, the central and state governments need to work together to deliver a viable business model so these important public goods are delivered at affordable unit cost and acceptable quality.
    By Rathin Roy

    We have a new government and renewed political space to address urgent short and medium-term economic challenges. I offer an aide-memoire specifying these.

    The present monetary policy framework is due to be revised in March 2021. While inflation has stayed within the mandated range, we need to consider whether this range is consistent with growth objectives, at what cost the inflation target is secured, and whether it has caused monetary dominance.

    In a context where the magnitude and quality of GoI’s fiscal deficit constrains its fiscal space, monetary dominance can make it difficult for the government to adhere to its fiscal targets, which, in turn, constrains private sector credit availability. These issues should inform the design of the next monetary policy framework.

    The central government has been shrinking in size (share of GDP). This needs to be recognised. To improve productivity and predictability of public expenditure, immediately introduce a medium-term fiscal framework to replace annual budgeting as the operational instrument for the execution of fiscal policy.

    This requires GoI to specify a medium-term expenditure ceiling assuming no significant increase in revenue-GDP ratios over the medium term. This would be the baseline to maintain fiscal prudence, such that expenditures only increase when there is more revenue.

    The government should also commission a review of three important areas of central expenditure: defence, internal security and railways, and specify resource envelopes for these over the next nine years.

    The operation of credit policy is currently unsatisfactory, and ultimately the exchequer bears the consequences. A major reason for this is that the trade-off between the prudential and other objectives of credit policy has not been clearly specified.

    To fix this, GoI, in consultation with RBI and other stakeholders, should first specify the volume of reserves RBI should hold for prudential reasons. Second, assign responsibility for the financial burden arising from any regulatory failure between RBI and the government. Third, draft a clear policy that specifies the purpose, cost and time frame of directed credit.

    These concrete short-term measures to improve the overall functioning of the macroeconomy are India-specific, and require policy actions that go beyond simply executing generic ‘counter-cyclical’ expansionary or contractionary measures.

    The major structural weakness that India faces is that, so far, growth is spurred by catering to the consumption of the top 15% of the population. Hence, the leading indicators of the economy so beloved to Mumbai are about sales of automobiles, two wheelers, air-conditioners, fast-moving consumer goods, etc.

    The goods consumed by all 1.2 billion Indians — nutritious food, affordable clothing, affordable housing and affordable health and education — do not figure. These areas of economic activity, that touch the lives of every Indian, are the indicators of economic progress on which GoI should focus.

    An important beginning has been made with the shift in emphasis to doubling farmers’ income, as opposed to maximising agricultural output, and with the emphasis on affordable housing.

    The task before GoI and the private sector is now to deliver a business model such that both agriculture and affordable housing provide opportunities for those in these businesses to earn at least 15% return, while those earning twice the minimum wage are able to meet the demand for these items without subsidy. (The rest can be subsidised if it is affordable.)

    In the case of clothing, there is a huge opportunity to undertake import substitution by locating these industries in the north and east of India where wages are competitive with Bangladesh and Vietnam.

    With health and education, the central and state governments need to work together to deliver a viable business model so these important public goods are delivered at affordable unit cost and acceptable quality.

    It is also important to recognise that quality economic growth has bypassed northern and eastern India. They have only benefited from remittance income from migration to the south and west.

    Some of this has occurred due to new economic opportunities in IT, manufacturing, diamond cutting, etc, but most of these migrants are in low paid, insecure service jobs. It is vital that this imbalance be addressed, as it is the major economic challenge to India’s integrity.

    The five sectors I mentioned above can deliver such jobs without waiting for a huge increase in existing capabilities in the poorer regions of the country where the majority live.

    India’s medium-term growth path would now be based on meeting home market demand in these five sectors of importance to all Indians, the spearhead of economic growth. Investments would be judged on how effective they are in securing this objective.

    Thus, a programme of import substitution to revive the affordable textile industry would involve fostering units in low-wage areas of northern and eastern India, rather than high wage islands close to the metropolitan regions.

    Production of intermediate goods for affordable housing would involve setting up production units that are dispersed to minimise logistic costs; this would mean that employment is created closer to where the unemployed live, rather than involving migration to concentrated urban hubs.

    Addressing these questions at the macro level, and assessing their positive impact on growth and employment, would be the principal economic policy task going forward.

    (Director, National Institute of Public Finance & Policy)
    (Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of
    (Catch all the Business News, Breaking News Events and Latest News Updates on The Economic Times.)

    14 Comments on this Story

    crusoe444 days ago
    Pl BJP , get the record keeping on jobs done. The congress knows what they didnt do in 55 years and are attacking your 5 years rule with it. Get the farm crises sorted out. It is difficult to belive that you cannot find five easy things to do and get it done in six months time. Have a list and get started on it. Get the huge pool of govt employees for record keeping.
    Get a panel of non govt economists( after weeding out the ****** communists from them) to advise on economic matters in parallel to north block economists and find the best solution. Stop the outflow of black money as much as possible. Catch the frauds in the banking system, the fraud company tycoons, and keep a sharp lookout for traitors and corrupt ordinance factory officers. I have heard from people in the know about the .....nathans and ......rajans who have strangle hold on ordinance factory corruption in stores.
    raaj till445 days ago
    if Govt allows Junta mandis to let producers to sell goods to consumers a growth rate of 10 % is possible... I am sure job growth can not come from high investment . it has come from dispersing and encouraging retail business and liberate them from Govt servants, fixers, and touts
    Lakshman Rao445 days ago
    From now on the opposition must show greater overall Responsibility for consttuctive debate in Parliament and not waste time and public resources
    Performance of Each MP must be closely monitored and published every quarter
    Inactive MPs who simply enjoy the perks must be audited
    The Economic Times