The Economic Times
English EditionEnglish Editionहिन्दी
| E-Paper

    Should a new investor invest in direct plans of mutual funds?


    If you are a new and inexperienced investor, here are the key things to know before you take the plunge.

    The knee-jerk reaction of always going for the cheapest option would not serve many investors well, except for knowledgeable do-it-yourselfers.
    ET Calculator Banner
    By Dhirendra Kumar

    In the five-plus years since the mutual funds regulator forced all funds to offer a direct-to-the-customer option, most well-informed investors have understood the advantage of direct plans.

    They know by now that all funds have a ‘direct from the manufacturer’ model, whereby investors can get a ‘direct’ equivalent of each scheme. These are cheaper too, as the fund house deducts lower expenses as it does not have to pay the ‘retailer’.

    Thus, cheaper translates to higher returns. How much higher are the returns from direct funds? A small amount annually, but with compounding over the years, it builds up. So does that mean that direct funds should be an automatic choice for all investors? Not quite. The 1% or so per year differential of returns that exists between direct and regular plans is money, but perhaps not too much of it.

    One could think of it as the money paid for the services of the distributor because that’s exactly what it is. The knee-jerk reaction of always going for the cheapest option would not serve many investors well, except for knowledgeable do-it-yourselfers. Whatever a mutual fund does for you is paid for by money that is deducted from your investments.

    For equity funds, fund companies can charge in slabs that go from a maximum of 2.5% to a minimum of 1.75%. There’s also GST and all of this put together can raise the high point of expenses to just short of 3%. While the rate is expressed on annual basis, the money is deducted every day in small amounts so that the annual charge adds up to the full amount. This money goes to the fund company, with some of it eventually going to the fund distributor who sold you the fund.

    While it is certainly arguable that mutual funds charge too much, the deduction is equal for all investors in a given mutual fund.

    To understand the choice between direct and regular investment, let’s first see what the ideal role of an adviser could be. In a list created by an old American financial company, here’s what an adviser should be doing: Trust or credibility development; goal planning, portfolio construction, portfolio rebalancing, ongoing goal planning and risk adjusting, and just as important as anything else, being a counselor when the market is going down. Even though that sounds like a tall order, most investors need some subset of these services. Beginner investors also need simple convenience services to facilitate the transactions.

    Even more than that, beginner investors need someone to get them started. Unlike a fixed deposit in a bank, a mutual fund investment is not simply an automatic extension of some services you are already getting. Being too focussed on the last sliver of cost may mean that you never actually get started.

    Based on all this, what kind of an investor would be suited for direct investments? That would have to be someone who understands what kind of mutual funds are needed for different kinds of investment needs, is capable of researching these independently and come up with a list of funds to invest in, and then go through the process of actually investing without the help of an intermediary. After one starts investing, whenever the markets fall and investment values come under pressure, an external source of advice can help one stay the course. Essentially, do for yourself everything that an adviser is supposed to do.

    Does this sound like you? If it does, then you could definitely earn some extra returns by investing directly. But if you are anything resembling a new and inexperienced investor, then you may be better off with a regular plan. Of course, this leads one to the question of whether it’s easy at all to find the right kind of adviser, but that’s a different story altogether.

    (The author is CEO, Value Research)

    ( Originally published on Jul 16, 2018 )
    (Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of
    (Click here to know how to save on taxes for the financial year 2020-21.)

    Download The Economic Times News App to get Daily Market Updates & Live Business News.

    13 Comments on this Story

    Vittal Singh939 days ago
    Looks like the author is trying to promote agents and brokers. Once the investor is educated direct mutual funds are always better.
    In case of regular mutual funds, commissions gets compounded over the years and becomes a significant amount. Moreover, there are online platforms which offers free advice and takes no commission. My investing has become easier and straightforward since I started using Invezta. On their home page they show how much I will lose if I pay commissions.
    SM Shah953 days ago
    This article only encourages agents, ideally Direct funds are much better than regular, basic education lies in every Indian. Most of the websites today give pretty good comparison, required literature, etc., One such is with really credible information on mutual funds.
    Awadhesh Kumar954 days ago
    Each one according to his/er taste. Direct plans are only a bait by AMCs to lure& trap the investor. Why should some one go for the direct plan if he''s working for his livelihood ? He must devote time at his workplace to improve his earning. MF investments can be done with an Advisor''s help. If not, if the investor can devote so much time to understand the market & invest directly, he can just as well invest directly into equities. So what''s the need of MFs ? MFs are needed bcoz they have made it their business to understand the market & play it which every retail investor can not do. If MFs are needed, so are advisors. It''s another story altogether whether good advisors are easily available. But then MFs were the same story in the beginning, everyone biting dust at the marketplace. They have learnt over the years. So will the advisors
    The Economic Times